Take: Can ocean technologies combat climate change?
Take on a podcast episode from The Land & Climate Podcast, originally published Fri, 26 Ju. Listen: https://www.landclimate.org/podcast/ TL;DR David Ho (Hawaiʻi, IPCC lead author) argues marine CDR isn’t ready — most techniques carry too many known unknowns to deploy. Fair and specific. Enthusiasm has cooled since ~2023 across CDR broadly, not just ocean. Matches what practitioners are seeing. Ocean iron fertilization: nutrient robbing effect only visible at scales we’ll never test. Models flag it, deployers dismiss it. Useful framing of the epistemic trap. Direct ocean removal is being added to IPCC methodology as a “political decision” despite research gaps. First time I’ve seen it stated this bluntly by a lead author. Governance gap: equilibration happens outside the deploying country’s EEZ — nobody’s worked out who claims the credit. Underrated issue. Bertie Harson-Bredinsky hosts David Ho of the University of Hawaiʻi at Mānoa, fresh off the 4th International Conference on Carbon Dioxide Removal in Milan and now a lead author on the IPCC methodology report covering CDR and CCUS. The conversation is a sober tour of marine CDR — iron fertilization, ocean alkalinity enhancement, direct ocean removal, and blue carbon — from someone who’s moved from cautiously curious to openly skeptical. Listen here: landclimate.org/podcast. ...